American Idol Idea....?

Why don't they do an All Star Version of American Idol next season and bring back people from the past? There are a handful of people who wouldn't be interested, like Carrie Underwood, Kelly Clarkson or Chris Daughtry, but can you imagine putting guys like Constantine and Michael Johns and Taylor Hicks against girls like Kimberly Locke and Kat McPhee and Fantasia? There are a lot of talented people from that show whose music careers never really took off. They would probably have to pay these people, and they would have to skip the auditions where they make fun of all of the retarded people, but wouldn’t that be the best season ever?